Snoopy with Scarf vs Snoopy Puffer Jacket: Which Winter Plush Fits?

Quick answer

Choose the Snoopy with Scarf 17 cm if you want a compact, classic winter look that fits small hands and tight display spots. Choose the Snoopy with Puffer Jacket 20 cm if you want a slightly larger, more padded cuddle companion with a bolder cold-weather outfit. Both are handmade Cream Peanuts plush from Bon Ton Toys, so the real decision comes down to size and outfit style.

Size and cuddle feel: 17 cm vs 20 cm

The Snoopy with Scarf is listed at 17 cm, while the Snoopy with Puffer Jacket is listed at 20 cm. That 3 cm difference matters most in the hand: the 17 cm version is easier for small children to carry, while the 20 cm version gives more surface area to hug and sits more visibly on a shelf or bed. Neither size is large, so if you want a plush that fills a chair or sofa, look at larger Bon Ton Toys options instead. If you are comparing this to the 25 cm Snoopy with Varsity Jacket, that one is the biggest of the three and has a sportier look.

Outfit design and winter character

The Snoopy with Scarf leans into a simple, classic winter accessory: a scarf. It reads as cozy and understated, and the smaller size keeps the scarf proportionally neat. The Snoopy with Puffer Jacket goes further with a puffer jacket, which gives Snoopy a chunkier, more bundled-up silhouette and a stronger visual statement. If you want the outfit to be the focal point, the puffer jacket is the more detailed choice. If you prefer a quieter, traditional winter look, the scarf version is the better fit.

Materials and care considerations

The Snoopy with Puffer Jacket is described as handmade with 100% recycled polyester filling, and the Peanuts plush line is noted as handmade. The Snoopy with Scarf listing does not specify filling or material details, so treat that as a decision limitation if recycled content is a priority for you. In practice, both are Cream-colored plush, which shows dirt more readily than darker fabrics. Spot-clean promptly and avoid soaking the outfits, since attached jackets and scarves can distort when wet.

Display and gifting angle

For a small shelf, desk, or nursery corner, the 17 cm scarf Snoopy takes up less room and pairs easily with other small Peanuts pieces. The 20 cm puffer Snoopy has more presence as a standalone gift or as the centerpiece of a winter-themed display. If you are building a collection, the two sizes and outfits are different enough to justify owning both without feeling redundant. If you only want one, pick based on whether you value compactness or a more padded, statement look.

Trade-offs to weigh

• Size vs portability: The 17 cm scarf Snoopy is easier to carry and store, while the 20 cm puffer Snoopy offers more to hold and a stronger shelf presence. Pick 17 cm for portability, 20 cm for presence.
• Outfit simplicity vs detail: The scarf is a simple, classic accessory; the puffer jacket is a chunkier, more detailed outfit that changes Snoopy's silhouette. Choose scarf for subtlety, puffer for a bolder winter look.
• Material transparency: The puffer jacket listing confirms 100% recycled polyester filling; the scarf listing does not specify filling or material details. If recycled content is a priority, the puffer version gives you that information upfront.

Product facts at a glance

• Snoopy with Scarf - 17 cm - 7 | Cream: Snoopy with Scarf is 17 cm, Cream, and part of the Peanuts plush line. The smaller size suits small hands and tight display spaces, and the scarf gives a classic winter look.
• Snoopy with Puffer Jacket 20 cm - 8'' | Cream: Snoopy with Puffer Jacket is 20 cm, Cream, handmade, and contains 100% recycled polyester. The larger size and puffer outfit create a bolder, more padded cuddle option, and the recycled filling is a plus if that matters to you.
• Snoopy with Varsity Jacket - 25 cm - 10 | Cream: Snoopy with Varsity Jacket is 25 cm, Cream, and part of the Peanuts plush line. If you want the largest of the jacket Snoopys, this is the one to compare against the 20 cm puffer.

Which winter Snoopy should you choose?

Best for

• Shoppers who want a compact winter Snoopy for small hands or tight shelves
• Fans of a classic, understated scarf look

Not for

• Anyone who wants the largest possible Snoopy plush (consider the 25 cm Varsity Jacket version instead)
• Shoppers who need confirmed recycled filling details on the scarf model